OIG Advisory Opinion: 08-15

    Favorable

    Multi-year gainsharing with annual rebasing to prevent duplicate payments

    Recorded opinion date:

    The commentary below transcribes Cabra's existing summary PDF. It preserves the original analysis, including its checklist and wording. The original PDF remains available below. Advisory opinions concern their particular facts and requestors; this commentary is not legal advice.

    What OIG Said

    OIG said multi-year percentage-based compensation creates kickback risk if earlier-accomplished savings carry forward across years, annual rebasing prevents duplicate payment for the same cost reductions.

    ✓A hospital paid cardiology groups 50% of cost savings over three years from implementing 30 specific cost reduction measures, compensation varied with performance and wasn't set in advance.

    ✓OIG acknowledged this doesn't fit the personal services safe harbor because aggregate compensation wasn't predetermined, and raised specific concerns about multi-year arrangements creating "improper duplication of physician payments."

    ✓OIG blessed it because of annual rebasing: at the end of year one, that year became the new baseline for year two calculations, preventing physicians from being paid repeatedly for the same cost reductions achieved in prior years.

    ✓The critical insight: without annual rebasing, multi-year gainsharing arrangements can result in "unearned duplicate payments" that amount to unlawful kickbacks even if the initial structure was legitimate.

    Diligence Checklist

    What you need to be ready to show in diligence

    ✓Implement annual rebasing for any multi-year performance-based compensation, and reset baselines at the end of each performance period so savings or improvements achieved in prior years aren't counted again in subsequent years.

    ✓Document the rebasing methodology clearly in contracts, show exactly how year-end results become the new baseline for the next period, eliminating duplicate payment risk.

    ✓Cap payments based on prior year Federal program volume, don't let increased referrals from existing physicians drive higher variable compensation in subsequent years.

    ✓Monitor whether savings in later years are actually new efficiencies or just carrying forward prior achievements, prove each payment period reflects fresh performance improvements.

    ✓Consider one-year terms instead of multi-year where feasible, OIG consistently notes that longer duration increases fraud and abuse risk, and multi-year arrangements "could well lead to a different result" without robust safeguards.

    If your multi-year MSO agreement, co-management arrangement, or value-based contract has percentage-based fees without annual rebasing, you're at risk of the "duplicate payment kickback" trap.

    Structure not diligence-ready?

    Cabra Consulting helps healthcare organizations make sure compensation and transaction structures are independently valued, clearly scoped, and defensible in diligence.

    Original PDF cover text

    FAVORABLE

    OIG WATCH 08-15

    Multi-year gainsharing with annual rebasing to prevent duplicate payments

    Cabra commentary publication date is not recorded in the existing source. No publication or revision date has been inferred from this HTML conversion.

    Source documents

    Preparing document preview…

    Ready to Move Forward?

    Let's explore how we can support your goals